Protect Yourself from Common Locksmith Scams
When you’re locked out, the last thing you want is to get taken advantage of.
Unfortunately, unlicensed locksmith scams have become more common across the U.S., including right here in New York.
They target people who are stressed, in a hurry, and willing to call the first phone number they find online.
Here’s how to recognize fake locksmiths and make sure you’re hiring a licensed, honest professional every time.
1. Beware of Unrealistic Prices
If you see an ad offering “$15 lockout service” – that’s your first red flag.
Scammers post fake prices to lure people in, then claim “extra fees” once they arrive.
You might end up paying hundreds more than quoted.
A legitimate locksmith will always provide a reasonable estimate upfront and explain what’s included before any work begins.
At Locksmith Plus, we provide transparent, written quotes before touching your lock.
2. Check for a Real Local Presence
Fake locksmith listings often use generic names like “24 Hour Locksmith” or “Quick Lock Service” and list fake addresses.
Search the company name on Google Maps and verify that it has a real physical or service-area address.
Legitimate locksmiths (like ours) have technicians based in specific neighborhoods – not random P.O. boxes.
3. Ask for License and Identification
In New York State, locksmiths are required by law to be licensed and carry valid identification.
Before work begins, ask to see:
· The locksmith’s state license
· A company ID or service badge
· A branded vehicle or uniform (most professional locksmiths have both)
If the person refuses or gets defensive – that’s a clear sign to stop the job immediately.
4. Watch for Drilling as a First Option
Scammers often jump straight to drilling because it’s the fastest (and most expensive) way to “solve” your problem.
Real locksmiths will always try non-destructive methods first – like lock-picking or decoding.
Drilling is only done as a last resort, and you should always approve it beforehand.
5. Look for Clear Branding and Communication
When you call, pay attention to how the phone is answered.
If someone picks up with a vague “Locksmith Service” instead of a company name – hang up.
A professional will answer with their brand name and provide details about location, pricing, and ETA right away.
6. Check Reviews and Online Presence
Search for consistent reviews across Google, Yelp, or the Better Business Bureau.
Watch out for dozens of short, generic five-star reviews all posted on the same day – they’re almost always fake.
A trustworthy business has a mix of honest, detailed customer feedback over time.
7. Never Pay Upfront Before Service
A licensed locksmith will never ask for full payment before arriving or before completing the job.
You should pay only after you’ve verified that the problem was solved as promised.
💡 Quick Checklist Before You Hire a Locksmith
✅ Verify the company’s name and license
✅ Ask for a written or texted quote before arrival
✅ Confirm the technician’s ID and vehicle branding
✅ Avoid companies that demand cash only
✅ Read at least a few recent reviews
🧠 Final Thoughts
Locksmith scams thrive on urgency and panic.
The best protection is to stay calm, verify, and ask questions.
A few seconds of checking can save you from being overcharged or having your lock unnecessarily destroyed.
At Locksmith Plus, we believe every customer deserves transparency, honesty, and peace of mind.
We’re proud to be a fully licensed, locally operated locksmith company serving Queens and Long Island – built on trust, not tricks.